I love my job. I love my school. I love my principal. She has such a great way of making meetings so relevant and useful, usually showing us strategies that we could replicate in our classrooms the very next day. There are actually many meetings I go to around our district that are like that. It’s kind of refreshing. So when we were taken through the protocol for discussing an article called “Save the Last Word For Me” on Friday, I decided that this time I would try it with my class. I teach 5th graders, after all–and amazing ones at that–so I knew they’d do great things with it.
Here’s the big idea:
We were using the article that’s in the picture here, which is about cloning. It gives some background and then highlights the pros and cons of the issue. As a means of ever more deeply discussing the topic, we tried this protocol in our small “heads together” groups this afternoon. I tried it with a small group of friends as an example first, and then sent them to work. I wish the video I had taken was of better quality, because it’s the kind of thing that makes more sense when you see it, rather than just read about it. Sorry. Maybe next time. 🙂
Overall, most groups did a great job, and most were able to dig a little deeper by hearing other people’s perspectives on what they had individually read first. Once we were finished, we debriefed and they shared what was hard for them about trying something like this for the first time. I heard them share the very same things that were hard for me as an adult reader and listener the first time–talking for the whole minute when it was my turn (that’s a lot longer that you realize when you aren’t sure what to say!), stopping when the minute was over (it’s a long time unless you have a really good idea to share, and then it’s AMAZINGLY short!), and only talking when it’s your turn (which is only once during each cycle of sharing). That last one didn’t surprise me, because I have a class of talkers. Or maybe I should call them arguers. No, debaters. And during this protocol, you are not allowed to comment on other people’s ideas unless you’re the next one in the circle. Anyway, they have important things to say and we’re all working together on finding the appropriate times to share our important thoughts.
Like I said before, I am always learning new things in my job as an adult learner, and when I can share those experiences and ideas with my kids, it’s a double bonus. We’ll use this one again, for sure, and I’ll be excited to share with you how it goes.
And so I’ll end with a short shout out to Mrs. Sisul and Mrs. Ford for using this protocol with me. Love that I learned it from you. 🙂
So have you heard of protocols before? Have you tried this one? What other ways do you use in your classroom to facilitate conversations around a text?